When sweet and sexy Mia ends up capturing the hearts of three best friends, it's a recipe for disaster. Brad, a suave Wall Street "suit," Zeke, a struggling screenwriter and sensitive Jonathan are young Manhattan professionals who pride themselves as successful bachelors on the prowl while Eric, their married friend, lives his life vicariously through stories of their sexual conquests. When each meet their dream woman on the same weekend and confide in one another that they are "whipped" at Sunday brunch, it doesn't take long for their dream to turn into a nightmare when all three realize they've fallen for the same woman.