Marty, a struggling writer, unlucky in love and unfulfilled professionally, has lost all hope until he meet not one, but two Ninas--Nina Cohen and Nina Harris. Nina Cohen is a smart and witty brunette with whom he finds much in common, while Nina Harris is a beautiful, sexy blonde that sweeps him off his feet when he crashes into the open door of the cab she is exiting. Unable to decide between the two, he begins dating both of them. Now he has two absolutely terrific women who are both attracted to him and actually want to be with him. However, stumbling over more than he can handle, Marty realizes that being lucky in love can mean being too lucky!