Five Better Choices for Magnum P.I. Than Matthew McConaughey

 
Actor Matthew McConaughey attends the premiere of Warner Bros. Pictures 'Fool's Gold' at Grauman's Chinese Theatre on January 30, 2008 in Hollywood, California
Getty Images

Ah, I see that the creative collapse of Hollywood continues with yet another rip-off from TV: we're getting a Magnum P.I. movie, and it's going to star Matthew McConaughey. Ugh. Worse, it's coming from Rawson Thurber, the writer-director of Dodgeball. Have these guys even seen the classic '80s TV show? Who decided that the new-millennium equivalent of "charming and frothy and fun" is "smarmy and juvenile and idiotic"?

Almost anyone would be better than Thurber, and almost anyone would be better than McConaughey in the starring role. Such as:

1. Josh Holloway
We know him now as the magnetic conman Sawyer on Lost, but can't you see him putting that bad-boy allure to good use as a crime-fighting ladies' man? We already know he looks great on the beach...

Josh Holloway



2. Russell Crowe
The Magnum move could go all intense and grim -- like Michael Mann's Miami Vice update -- with the likes of Crowe in the driver's seat of Robin Masters' Ferrari.

Russell Crowe



3. Connor Trinneer
You don't know who is he, because he's the most criminally underused actor on television. But if you saw him steal Star Trek: Enterprise from Scott Bakula, then you know what I'm talking about. He's got all-American charisma with a dangerous edge -- just like Magnum -- and can do laid-back that doesn't make you think "brain-dead."

Connor Trinneer



4. Will Smith
Magnum was a regular guy, but in a grownup way that the likes of overgrown frat boy McConaughey can't hope to match. Who's our new everyman for the 21st century? Of course it's Will Smith. Which means that the new TC, Magnum's sidekick, could be played by a goofy white guy. It could even be McConaughey.

Will Smith



5. Tom Selleck
Hey, if Harrison Ford can pick up Indiana Jones's fedora and bullwhip after 25 years, why can't Selleck put on the Hawaiian shirt again? It'd be fun to catch up with what Magnum's been up to in recent years.

Tom Selleck



Oh, and Higgins? Must be played by Ewan McGregor.

-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
MaryAnn Johanson (email me)
reviews, reviews, reviews! at FlickFilosopher.com

Comments
post a comment
Add your voice to the conversation and share your opinions. Please keep your comments relevant to this post. Inappropriate or purely promotional comments may be removed.

Read our comment guidelines for more information.

You are not signed in. You need to be registered and signed in to add a comment.
Free Film
Elaine Cassidy in Temple Film & TV Productions Ltd.'s 'Disco Pigs'
Temple Film & TV Productions Ltd.

Disco Pigs

In Film.com's latest movie of the week, Disco Pigs, two Irish kids (Pig and Runt), inseparable since birth, find their close relationship challenged by growing pains.
Take the Film.com Survey