To all outward appearances, Brewster is an idyllic little town with wide, clean streets, green parks brimming with happy children and a booming economy. But trouble comes to paradise when a mysterious, clean-cut stranger, Whiley Pritcher arrives. Through a local public access program, OUR TOWN, he poses the question, "What's wrong with Brewster?" And as Pritcher probes callers, his question uncovers long-simmering skeletons in the town closet which eventually explode into violence and tragedy.