Editor's Note: Earlier, we poked a little fun at My Sister's Keeper. So, in the interest of fair play, here's another take.
A few years ago I read one of those books. The kind you can't put down even though you recognize the flaws and know it can't end well. Maybe I picked it up because it was there -- I had received it as a Christmas gift -- maybe I kept reading it because it made me feel less bad about some of my own parenting decisions or maybe because it actually is a good, if heartbreaking, story. Whatever the reasons, Jodi Picoult's My Sister's Keeper grabbed and kept my attention despite its subject matter and even after I (correctly) figured out how it would end.
I should not have been surprised to learn it was being made into a film. The book, a family drama, reads as if cinema were the medium the author had in mind to begin with. Doesn't this synopsis from the

